
The National Post’s Brian Hutchinson points out the obvious solution for the conflict of interest CBC reporter Stephen Smart is in with his Victoria legislature beat:
“For everyone’s sake, the CBC should offer Mr. Smart a better assignment” (see here)
The problem is then CBC news director Wayne Williams would have to admit to his error in judgement which is plain to anyone unattached to this closed little private group.
To get an idea how these journos protect each other, check out this unbelievably idiotic defence of Smart by Postmedia’s Craig McInnis who has the audacity to illogically use feminism as a reason to allow this kind of conflict of interest:
“The notion competing professional interests can’t coexist under one roof dates back to the not-so-distant past when the model family consisted of hubby heading off to work and the good wife staying home and supporting him in every way.” (see here)
McInnis though is just the result of being egged on by the likes of Global’s Keith Baldrey who is relishing in his role of enforcer of this cadre:
Jan 20 – “I hear Stephen Smart is staying put as CBC’s ledge bureau chief. If true, good move by CBC. Looks like news div. wins out, as it should be.”
To which I replied:
“Shameful to be celebrating an obvious journo conflict of interest with the Liberal government”
This led to a bit of back and forth culminating with me asking him this:
“You were at Smart’s wedding to Bill Good’s former producer Rebecca Scott and sat beside Christy Clark right?”
Baldrey:
“I sat beside a lot of people that night. Lots of moving around. But so what?”
This evidence of how tight the BC media are with the Liberals is either an example of Baldrey not being able tell where the line of professionalism is or a case of him being intentionally obtuse. Either way, it’s a stunning omission of a lack of journalistic principles and integrity.
Then on Jan 23rd after Baldrey once again tried to play the media’s well-worn game of “you’d be fine if it was a Conservative…” I asked him about another blogger accusing him of squashing a Christy Clark/ BC Rail story:
“Speaking of biases, is it true as Alex Tsakumis says, you lobbied management at Global to have a Christy Clark story spiked?”
Baldrey:
“No.”
Me:
“So, he lied about that as well as you being a golfing buddy of David Hahn [BC Ferries CEO]? You ok with him lying about those?”
Baldrey:
“You’re a whiny, churlish little man. End of discussion. You’re a nobody who throws accusations out. Good-bye.”
How asking the same kind of questions a real reporter would pose makes me “whiny” is bizarre but what is really telling, is him calling me “a nobody”.
It gives you quite the insight into Baldrey’s world where he and the Liberal élite are ‘somebody’s’ and the rest of us should shut the heck up and don’t dare question them.
PS: I have had a few interactions with Stephen Smart and he has always been extremely professional and seems like a great guy.